The FisCalc
// INSURANCE COST ANALYSIS

Insurance Cost
Calculator

Compare life, TPD, trauma, and income protection premiums inside vs outside super. See the real drag on your salary and super balance — and which structure makes more sense for your situation.

// YOUR_PROFILE
Premium rates are age and gender rated. Enter your details for accurate estimates.
Gender
Smoker
// COVER_TYPES
Toggle on the types of cover you hold or want to compare.
Life Insurance
Active
INSIDE SUPER
$177/mth
OUTSIDE SUPER
$212/mth
TPD Insurance
Active
Trauma (Critical Illness)
Outside only
income
Off

Your data stays on your device — nothing is stored or sent.

Total Inside Super (annual)
$3,950
$329/month from super
Total Outside Super (annual)
$6,845
9.2% of monthly take-home
Super Drag Over 20yr
$183,883
opportunity cost at 7.5% growth
Monthly Take-Home Impact
9.2%
$570/mth if held outside
// PREMIUM_COMPARISON
CoverInside Super /mthOutside Super /mthSuper drag /yrSalary impact
Life Insurance
$1.00m
$177$2121.18%3.4%
Inside super: premiums paid from pre-tax super contributions, but death benefit may be taxed up to 32% if paid to non-dependants. Outside super: premiums are not tax-deductible (for individuals), but proceeds are generally tax-free.
TPD Insurance
$750,000
$153$2291.02%3.7%
Inside super: 'any occupation' definition only (more restrictive). Cheaper due to group rates and tax treatment. Outside super: 'own occupation' available (pays if you can't do your specific job), but premiums are not tax-deductible.
Trauma (Critical Illness)
$300,000
N/A$1302.1%
Trauma insurance CANNOT be held inside super. It must be purchased outside super. Premiums are not tax-deductible for individuals. Benefits are paid as a lump sum directly to you, tax-free.
Total
$329$5702.19%9.2%
// SUPER_DRAG_IMPACT
Annual premium as % of super balance. High drag erodes your retirement outcome.
Life Insurance1.18% of super balance/yr
$2,120/yr20yr opportunity cost: $98,691
TPD Insurance1.02% of super balance/yr
$1,830/yr20yr opportunity cost: $85,191
Premium estimates are indicative only, based on published benchmark rates for standard occupational risk. Actual premiums vary by insurer, health status, occupation, pastimes, and sum insured. Always get quotes from multiple insurers or an insurance broker. Not financial advice.

Next Step

Review with a Superannuation Specialist

Verify contribution strategies match structural index limits.

Total inside super: $3,950/yr
Get Started →

🔒 Your inputs never leave your browser window. Calculations run entirely client-side.

Life, TPD, trauma and income protection: inside vs outside super

Most Australians have default life and TPD insurance inside their super fund. It feels cheap because you do not see it leave your bank account — but it quietly erodes your super balance every year. Understanding the true cost, and whether to hold insurance inside or outside super, is one of the most underappreciated personal finance decisions you can make.

Life insurance: inside vs outside super

Life insurance held inside super is generally cheaper because premiums are paid from pre-tax super contributions and group rates apply. The key catch: benefits paid to adult non-dependants (such as adult children) can be taxed at up to 32% including Medicare levy. Benefits paid to a spouse or financially dependent children are generally tax-free.

TPD: the "any occupation" problem

TPD inside super must use the "any occupation" definition — you can only claim if you are unable to work in ANY job for which you are reasonably suited by education, training, or experience. Outside super, "own occupation" cover is available, which pays if you cannot perform your specific occupation. A surgeon with an "own occupation" policy can claim if they can no longer perform surgery, even if they could theoretically work in administration.

Trauma: only available outside super

Trauma (critical illness) insurance cannot be held inside super under Australian superannuation law. It must be purchased and paid for outside super. This means premiums are after-tax dollars, but benefits are paid as a tax-free lump sum directly to you without any superannuation or trustee involvement.

Income protection: the tax deduction advantage

Income protection held outside super is one of the few insurance premiums that is tax-deductible for individuals. For someone on a 37% marginal tax rate, a $3,000/year premium effectively costs only $1,890 after tax. Inside super, no deduction is available and benefits are limited to two years for policies started after 31 March 2020.

How much life insurance do I actually need?
The most widely used formula is the income replacement method: multiply your annual income by 10, then add any outstanding debts (mortgage, car loan, personal loans) and subtract existing assets (super balance, savings). A 40-year-old earning $120,000 with a $600,000 mortgage and $150,000 in super would need approximately $1,650,000 in cover ($1,200,000 income replacement + $600,000 debt − $150,000 super). The logic is that the lump sum, invested conservatively at 5–6%, generates enough income to replace your salary for your dependants indefinitely. This is a starting point — adjust upward if you have young children, a non-working partner, or private school commitments. Review your cover amount after every major life event: children, property purchase, significant salary increase, or divorce.
Should I hold insurance inside or outside super?
The answer depends on your tax situation and who will receive the benefit. Inside super is cheaper (pre-tax premiums, group rates) and suits younger people who need large cover at low cost. Outside super is better when: (a) your intended beneficiary is an adult non-dependant (adult child, sibling) — because benefits paid outside super to non-dependants are tax-free, while super death benefits to non-dependants face up to 32% tax; (b) you want own-occupation TPD rather than any-occupation; (c) you need trauma cover, which cannot be held in super at all. A common structure is: life cover inside super (cost-effective, paid from pre-tax contributions), trauma outside super (mandatory), and income protection outside super (premiums are tax-deductible, claims are taxable income).
Is income protection insurance worth it?
For anyone without substantial liquid assets — typically most Australians under 55 — income protection is the highest-priority personal insurance purchase. Default super funds provide some income protection cover, but it is usually limited to 2 years of benefit period and at lower income replacement rates than standalone policies. A standalone income protection policy can replace up to 70% of your pre-disability income for an agreed benefit period (2 years, 5 years, or to age 65). Premiums are fully tax-deductible when held outside super, which reduces the real cost significantly at higher tax rates. A self-employed person or sole trader with no sick leave entitlement has zero income protection without an explicit policy — the exposure is catastrophic relative to the premium cost.
How does default super insurance affect my super balance?
Default life and TPD insurance inside super is funded by deductions from your super balance — typically $400–$1,200/year depending on your fund, age, and cover level. For younger members with small balances, the drag is proportionally significant: $600/year in premiums on a $20,000 balance is a 3% annual cost before investment returns. Compounded over a working life, unnecessary or duplicate insurance cover inside super can cost tens of thousands in foregone retirement savings. This is why ASIC's 2019 Protecting Your Super reforms prohibited funds from providing default insurance to members under 25 or with balances below $6,000 without explicit opt-in. Review your fund's insurance deductions annually in your super statement and consider whether the cover level justifies the cost.

// SMSF_INSURANCE

If you have or are considering an SMSF, insurance inside an SMSF is structured very differently. Check the SMSF cost calculator.

SMSF Cost Calculator →

// ADVICE_COST

Insurance structuring is a common reason to engage a financial adviser. See when advice fees pay for themselves.

Advice Cost Calculator →